Welcome to the new FlexRadio Community! Please review the new Community Rules and other important new Community information on the Message Board.
Need the latest SmartSDR, Power Genius, Tuner Genius and Antenna Genius Software?
SmartSDR v3.8.20 and the SmartSDR v3.8.20 Release Notes
SmartSDR v2.12.1 and the SmartSDR v2.12.1 Release Notes
Power Genius XL Utility v3.8.9 and the Power Genius XL Release Notes v3.8.9
Tuner Genius XL Utility v1.2.11 and the Tuner Genius XL Release Notes v1.2.11
Antenna Genius Utility v4.1.8
SmartSDR v3.8.20 and the SmartSDR v3.8.20 Release Notes
SmartSDR v2.12.1 and the SmartSDR v2.12.1 Release Notes
Power Genius XL Utility v3.8.9 and the Power Genius XL Release Notes v3.8.9
Tuner Genius XL Utility v1.2.11 and the Tuner Genius XL Release Notes v1.2.11
Antenna Genius Utility v4.1.8
If you are having a problem, please refer to the product documentation or check the Help Center for known solutions.
Need technical support from FlexRadio? It's as simple as Creating a HelpDesk ticket.
Need technical support from FlexRadio? It's as simple as Creating a HelpDesk ticket.
S-Meter Accuracy of FLex and Others - Rob Sherwood
HCampbell WB4IVF
Member ✭✭
3
Comments
-
0
-
@Jim
Traditional S-Meters circuits were designed to INTEGRATE A 500HZ passband not peak In fact NONE of the Japanese radios do either1 -
For me, the accuracy of an S-meter's calibration is useful for testing but is over rated and over used for communications purposes. To me, S-meter accuracy is of little value on any manufacturer's radio. Any relative indication of signal and noise strength is all one needs for letting the other station know if you can copy them. The meter reading is more an indication of the path. The station is a factor but only a small part of the equation at best with propagation being, by far, the dominant factor. It seems to me that absolute S-meter readings are used most often these days to feed the ego of the person on the opposite end of a QSO and does little to help the distant station make adjustments such as turning on the AMP or rotating the beam, Etc. So often I hear "you're rig is doing a great job. 30 over here", when it's the propagation that was contributing the most to the meter reading and QRP would have been entirely adequate. You've probably heard the old adage that I worked that station with a wet noodle. In other words, propagation was great and the main reason for the success of the contact. In reverse, the same "he-man" kilowatt station is received with an S-9 meter reading but a local noise source is also S-9 so the communications is marginal or non-existent. What did the S-meter reading tell the distant station in either of these two cases? In my estimation, nothing of real value. For me, the real indication of signal value is the signal to noise ratio. In other words, the signal strength above the total noise strength in the receiver pass band. Any somewhat linear relative strength meter will give you these values, calibrated or not. This SNR, communicated to the the distant station, versus an S-meter reading, is a much better indication of your ability to copy the intelligence being transmitting. No egos involved!1
-
Is that 500 Hz. bandwidth of sampling for 0 to 500 Hz. or some where in between. It would seem if the latter were true, a person with a low voice response would register higher on the S-meter than one with a higher pitched voice.
1 -
3
-
I'll make it simple when the receiver has a dummy load for an antenna I want it to read zero on my 6400M like on my KX3 and formally on my 7300. Currently it read S7 on 80 meters on the 6400M and slightly lower on other bands.1
-
@Burt
What you are asking for is that the S-Meter Read a TOTALLY MEANINGLESS IRRLEVENT NUMBER...which while it gives you great comfort that there is no external signal on the terminals is not related to anything that the radio may actually be hearing.
1 -
How could the radio be hearing anything when I have a dummy load for an input?
My power meter reads zero if I turn the power down to zero, that is nothing going out, zero, so nothing coming in should be zero.0 -
Thermal noise in the front end of the radio?1
-
Flex good job on my FLEX 6600 S-Meter , it may seem strange I kept a log from 6500 to now on FLEX 6600 on S-meter reading I would change the normal 59 reading in AC LOG to the actual reading from the FLEX Smart SDR screen. One Ham said I'm only S-9+10 I'm running 1500 watts I discounted him as a rookie with deep pocket. well don't shoot me for that statement. hi hi . ...1
-
All radios have internal noise, the flex is simply reporting the signal in the Receiver bins, sampling..coverting that noise to RF and sending that to the meter. So yes the radio hears internal noise.
Steve Hicks has writen so much on this explaining all this and yet so many still can't get their heads around the technology.1 -
0
-
I think this is true. It could be a Flex feature or someone could write it using the API and make a "traditional s-meter" available as an application that could be run alongside SmartSDR.1
-
Never thought people would be upset having an accurate meter...lol1
-
0
-
@Burt
The S-Mater is reading the actual receiving level at the radio's antenna,
This may be hard to get your head around on...
But I will try to explain.
If your radio on 20M is capable of a Minimum Discernible Signal of say -115dBm then it should be reading S2 (-127dBm plus 2x6dBm - 115dBm)... If you short the antenna, it still can't hear any better than S2.. so reading an Arbitrary S0 is absolutely meaningless because its not hearing S0 but it is hearing S2.
In fact, if the shorted across the antenna were perfect and it was really cold (like absolute zero) then the true number should be -143dBm or MINUS S2.5
The Japanese Radios copied the Old AGC Voltage Circuits to give an arbitrary S Meter reading... so if you shorted the antenna, you got 0 AGC voltage and it displays as S0 - which of course is absolutely meaningless... except that it feels logical even if it is not...
2 -
I would label the Relative S Meter as the Bu** SH*$ meter2 -
I can hear it now! "You're S-9 plus 20 dB on my Flex. To understand what I'm telling you, go to www.flexradio.com and download the manual. Note that I've selected S-meter option 47. From this, use your scientific RPN calculater to determine what 20 over means with option 47. You'll still have a meaningless indication of what I'm hearing because I've not yet told you the band noise level at my station. GOOD LUCK".
73 & LOL!2 -
1
-
1
-
0
-
Lets call it the "Feel Good Meter"
It might make you feel good but it's still meaningless.
1 -
Roger out.
0 -
Wait... do y'all people actually look at the S-Meter? I tell everyone I like that they are 20 over 9. Then they like me!4
-
1
-
3
-
2
-
I am with you Burt:
Not caring about the mombo jumbo overly complicated math and convoluted explanations on this that and the other hearing one thing or another inside the radio. If the antenna connector is shorted or disconnected/ connected to a dummy load I want to see "0" because that is what it is actually seeing. No signal No reading ~:~1 -
NOT TRUE... Definitely NOT MUMBO JUMBO... Basic Math...
When you short the Antenna, you are seeing the Minimum Discernible Signal that the radio is capable of receiving at that Frequency.
S0 by International Standard Definition is -127dBm
If your radio reads Zero when you short the antenna... then any and all S-Meter Readings on that meter are totally wrong.
BUT if it makes you happy to see a totally wrong and totally irrelevant number suggest you buy any Japanese radio.
3 -
Every other receiver, transceiver I ever owned (S-76, Swan-240, Kenwood TS-940, Hallicrafters, HQ-145, HQ-170, Icom 751, Icom 746, 756), from 1959 read zero or near zero with no antenna. That's what I want now I am not interested in the purity argument. I am not interested in random electrons and holes crashing and making INTERNAL receiver noise. Although the pretty colors on the S-meter are nice let zero be zero.0
Leave a Comment
Categories
- All Categories
- 292 Community Topics
- 2.1K New Ideas
- 537 The Flea Market
- 7.5K Software
- 6K SmartSDR for Windows
- 146 SmartSDR for Maestro and M models
- 363 SmartSDR for Mac
- 250 SmartSDR for iOS
- 231 SmartSDR CAT
- 174 DAX
- 355 SmartSDR API
- 8.8K Radios and Accessories
- 7K FLEX-6000 Signature Series
- 41 FLEX-8000 Signature Series
- 851 Maestro
- 44 FlexControl
- 848 FLEX Series (Legacy) Radios
- 802 Genius Products
- 420 Power Genius XL Amplifier
- 279 Tuner Genius XL
- 103 Antenna Genius
- 245 Shack Infrastructure
- 167 Networking
- 404 Remote Operation (SmartLink)
- 130 Contesting
- 635 Peripherals & Station Integration
- 125 Amateur Radio Interests
- 875 Third-Party Software