SmartSDR v3.8.19 and the SmartSDR v3.8.19 Release Notes | SmartSDR v2.12.1 and the SmartSDR v2.12.1 Release Notes
SmartSDR v1.12.1 and the SmartSDR v1.12.1 Release Notes
Power Genius XL Utility v3.8.8 and the Power Genius XL Release Notes v3.8.8
Tuner Genius XL Utility v1.2.11 and the Tuner Genius XL Release Notes v1.2.11
Antenna Genius Utility v4.1.8
Need technical support from FlexRadio? It's as simple as Creating a HelpDesk ticket.
Give us a Choice with the S Meter
Comments
-
I assume you have tried clicking on the dBm/S meter in a slice? It toggles the view from dBm to S meter.
I doubt introducing a "broken" S meter will be considered. Good thing it's an open API platform and you can write your own meter then!1 -
I'm probably too dumb to no how OM. Golly, I like spenting sevral thoosand dolars for an S meter that reeds S4 with know anntena cunected and fer the abilaty to wrote my own softwarz.0
-
You are irritated from having a lab accurate signal meter? This is the high tech world of Flex radio and direct sampling. your asking for an inaccurate meter on the Flex? I don't think so..lol3
-
Suggested reading>>>>>>
1 -
I always thought my signal report to the other station was a function of how badly I needed their QSL card!8
-
Yup you did, welcome to direct sampling1
-
Sorry Bill ! This is an IDEA for an OPTIONAL software switch to go from (so called) lab grade to relative. I doubt there is such a thing as a lab grade S meter anyway, as there are several S meter standards in use. Who is to say what the lab grade standard is? Flex is great, but the engineers at Collins, Kenwood, Icom, Yaesu and so forth are not idiots either. Just saying. OPTIONAL SWITCH PLEASE!0
-
The Kool-Aid stand is open.0
-
W7NGA - Yup! You are correct on that OM! hahaha
OMG what have I started?0 -
As it says, not planned.
The engineers at all the companies you mentioned are not idiots as you said. but an SDR radio works in a much different manner then all those radios. And yes you could use the Flex in a lab or a test bench to calibrate other radios and there is a standard. Voltage= S unit.
0 -
My 75S3 is 100uV for S-9, my R4C is 50uV, my NC-303 I have no idea, and the calibration varies with frequency.
I like the Flex calibrated meter that tells me the signal level at the antenna terminal and seems to be unaffected by frequency and is unaffected by the preamp. Absolute accuracy, compared to what, I don't know, but it is repeatable.
On the other hand, S-meters have been somewhat controversial for signal reports for as long as I can remember and the "live" or "liberal" S-meter is important to some.
Your proposal is not one I would request, but for others it may be important.
1 -
Bill - sorry. So what is not planned? Taking suggestive and creative ideas from your customers or taking future purchases? This is an idea, and no Bill, an S meter should not read S4 without an antenna connected as like you noted there is no voltage at the input! This is starting to remind me of Gotham antenna claims. :-) (Tongue in cheek and in a friendly spirit)0
-
I take it you did not read the link posted here for you to read? in that post Steve explains this in a way most of us can understand.
Without an antenna there is always voltage, internal. The receive bins are always being read,there is always voltage in the bins, they are always active. This is what the meter reflects. This is how direct sampling works in the Flex. It is working correctly as designed.
Not planned simply means what it says, the idea is not planned.0 -
Thanks Lionel, I think I am treading very close to being banned from the Flex site for not drinking down the Kool Aid. :-) Seriously, I do love my Flex. Holy Grail? No. But very good none-the-less.0
-
So you are content with a broken S meter than can't read below S4. OK ...0
-
Rex your comments are always welcome, you think out of the box. I am just trying to help you understand how the meter works in the Flex and why it does and says what it does. It is not a design flaw. And I don't get your comment about cool aid?0
-
Rex, to show you how it works try this. Place your mouse over the left edge of the pass band filter and move the filter so as to narrow it up, you will notice the S meter reading will drop as you move it. If you keep going and make as narrow as possible the S meter should read near S 1
The width of the pass band filter reflex how many bins are active and being read.1 -
@Rex You have legitimately posted your request fir a switch to convert the accurate Flex S-Meter into a more traditional innacurate Relative S-Meter similar to the approximations of signal strength derived from Legacy AGC Loops. Since Flex does not use Legacy AGC loops it might be hard to implement I can understand that many people would gain comfort from the fiction of those readings WHERE no antenna attached implies S0 even though the Minimum Discernable signal is not -127dBm but rather something like -110dBm or S4. Anyways I Always thought all DX and contest signal reports were 5/9 whatever. Hi. Hi. While I personally applauded the demise of legacy S-Meters Let’s see how many likes you get.3
-
Continuing with the Legacy Fiction S—Meter.
‘
If you receive a S9 or -73dBm signal and add 30dB gain in the preamp. A Legacy AGC loop will read S9+30dB. But your signal really is still -73dBm at the antenna and all the preamp should have done is reduced your noise floor by 30dB.
But again I can understand how people can prefer to enjoy the comfort of the fiction that a preamp makes a received signal at the antenna stronger because lowering the relative noise floor makes it seem so.3 -
I and many group members have access to the Wood Box S-Meter which looks like a traditional analog D'Arsonval (sp) meter. Don't think that's available on the web any longer. Still, in the direct sampling environment, it mirrors the values displayed on the regular Flex S-meter.
Just for the heck of it, I switched on my IC 7300 which currently sits with no antenna connected. It does show S-0. I'm not asking Flex to change their S-Meter. Apparently, Icom, probably as a cave in to the knob and dial operators, made the decision to carry over the "inaccurate" S-meter tradition to their version of the direct sampling world.
Who needs an S-meter anyway. The important thing is that you can hear/copy the other station, right?
0 -
Cheers Bill. My thoughts exactly.
The comedy here is that on eham.net, a fellow called Zenki goes ballistic all the time for lack of calibrated accurate S-meters on Yaesu, Icom, Kenwood, etc.
But HERE, Rex wants the old un-calibrated relative style back! (No offense Rex, but you will make Zenki's head explode :-) [good entertainment indeed!] )
That said, as mentioned by K6OZY, with the API, there is no limit to the number of third party utilities that people can write and provide. (In a perfect world, there is also little limit to features that FRS can build into SmartSDR and the firmware, but you do know that FRS does not employ thousands of programmers like IBM or HP?) Hence, just like with DDutil and SliceMaster and FRstack, it makes perfect sense for some third party to build a general purpose metering application that would let you pick and display all types of metering options for the rig.
Cheers,
Neal1 -
Unplug antenna and leave radio on and software turn on some light switches and electric motors or appliances you will see the flexradio is very much listening to local noise floor all the time.
Look at the birdies from you router on 6 meters.!
73 Jeff
0 -
I thought all signals were 5 9 anyway as evidenced in contests. You're 5x9, what's your call!
0 -
AFIK none of the Legacy Radios actually use a calibrated RF Voltmeter at the antenna to measure the true received signal voltage. (There might be some that I do not know about)
Instead S-Meter readings are derived from the AGC Loop, hence when one adds 30dB preamp gain to the radio, the S-Meter jumps 30dB even though the actually received signal voltage at the antenna has no changed and when one removes the antenna, there is no AGC hence it reads S0 even though the radio cannot read a signal below S4 or -103dBm
But heck if it makes you happy to have a fictitious number give you comfort that your preamp in working or your radio is not hearing anything with the antenna disconnected then by all means vote for this idea.
1 -
S meter numbers don't matter anyway since no matter what the level your always S-9 just listen to the contests your S9 even though I had to ask for you to repeat your call sign 8 times your signal is S9 maybe my hearings bad ....1
-
Hi Howard:
I am also a new Flex 6600 owner, and coming from the analog superhet world, I too was confused at first, actually until yesterday, about the different behavior on the Flex due to the different technology and measurement method. I would propse that part of this problem, and maybe endless support calls and forum posts, is because FRS has not yet added a chapter to the user manual that is titled "Coming to Direct Sampling SDR from the SuperHet Analog World?; What is different & What to Expect".
Such a chapter would have shortened my learning curve by perhaps weeks, and saved a ton of forum posts.
For example, you can see this slow learning curve and confusion here;
https://community.flexradio.com/flexradio/topics/6600-maestro-settings-help-needed
Again, the radio works great and has really impressed me as a lab grade tool,
but what I was witnessing, using my previous radios as experience, was not what
I thought. And without a chapter in the manual, I did not know if I had a problem,
or if it was simply a different design, method of measuring, or what.
So in summary; It seems that threads like this, and feature requests like this, are
due to people using their previous analog radios as a frame of reference, and thinking
that new SDR radios need to feel/look the same way, else they may be broken.
The solution is having that extra chapter, whereby each and every buyer can easily see the educational material during the first few days of reading.
Cheers,
Neal4 -
Very Good suggestion0
-
You seem to have a point Wayne :-)
A. If I am rag chewing with you, and can hear you, I could care less what the S-Meter says.
B. If I am contesting, yup, it's always S9 replies, so I don't even need to look.
Hmm, I guess I don't really need one after all! :-)
But I still think that someone should use the API, and try to make an old analog AGC style
inaccurate relative S-Meter, just to infuriate Zenki and provide new Flex owners with choice.
Cheers,
Neal2 -
Here is a link to the Woodbox Radio ANALOG S-Meter
https://www.dropbox.com/s/223si9ks962n1av/Smart%20S-meter_V1.6.zip?dl=0
Looks and feels like one of the Legacy Meters but unfortunately unlike legacy meters it still gives you an accurate reading rather than an AGC Loop Approximation so 30dB Preamp gain does NOT increase the reading at the antenna
3 -
As I commented on a similar thread in the Facebook Flex group, "If you've got my call right, you're 5-9 or 599." Served me well for over 50 years...
0
Leave a Comment
Categories
- All Categories
- 280 Community Topics
- 2.1K New Ideas
- 523 The Flea Market
- 7.5K Software
- 6K SmartSDR for Windows
- 144 SmartSDR for Maestro and M models
- 349 SmartSDR for Mac
- 247 SmartSDR for iOS
- 228 SmartSDR CAT
- 168 DAX
- 351 SmartSDR API
- 8.7K Radios and Accessories
- 7K FLEX-6000 Signature Series
- 838 Maestro
- 43 FlexControl
- 842 FLEX Series (Legacy) Radios
- 786 Genius Products
- 413 Power Genius XL Amplifier
- 274 Tuner Genius XL
- 99 Antenna Genius
- 238 Shack Infrastructure
- 162 Networking
- 398 Remote Operation (SmartLink)
- 124 Contesting
- 618 Peripherals & Station Integration
- 122 Amateur Radio Interests
- 856 Third-Party Software